The Fear of Undoing
The central problem with Are You Ready for a World Without Patriarchy? is not that it asks hard questions. It is that it asks them from inside a frame that has already decided the answers. The essay presents itself as sober realism pushing back against naive idealism, but much of its force comes from exaggerating harms on one side while naturalizing, and at times aestheticizing, harms on the other.
This imbalance begins early, in the move from a single anecdote to a civilizational thesis.
The dinner-date story is treated as a philosophical stress test, but it does not bear the weight the author places on it. A woman expecting a man to check a noise is read not as inconsistency or ambivalence, but as proof that feminist critique collapses under pressure. The conclusion follows too quickly. Human beings routinely hold mixed commitments. They accept some norms while rejecting others. That...



